Recency Bias – Falling Into the Past Returns Trap

Introduction

It’s tempting to assume that a fund which performed well recently will continue to do so. That’s recency bias — a cognitive shortcut where recent events heavily influence decisions.

In mutual fund investing, this often means buying into funds at their peak performance, only to suffer when reality corrects. Let’s explore this trap with a real-world story of Raj and his trending fund mistake.

13/06/2025

What is Recency Bias in Mutual Fund Investing?

Recency bias is the tendency to:

· Overweight recent performance while ignoring long-term track record

· Assume short-term winners will stay winners

· Neglect risk, asset quality, or valuation

This often results in poor entry timing and unrealistic return expectations.

Real-Life Example: Raj and the Top Fund Trap

In early 2022, Raj saw a small-cap fund deliver 40%+ returns in the previous year. Impressed, he invested ₹3 lakhs without checking past volatility or fund fundamentals.

But markets corrected, small-caps slumped, and the fund fell by 18% in the next 12 months. Raj’s CAGR after 2 years was just 5.2%.

Had he chosen a diversified flexi-cap or balanced fund, his return might have been closer to 9–10% with lower downside.


Key Takeaways

Recency Bias vs Long-Term Thinking
Behaviour Recency Bias Long-Term Thinking
Decision Trigger Recent high returns 3–5 year performance, volatility
Fund Choice Popular, overbought funds Well-rated, consistent funds
Outcome Enter at peak, underperform Enter at fair value, grow steadily

Conclusion

Past returns are just one piece of the puzzle. Relying solely on them invites disappointment. Instead, combine performance, volatility, consistency, and investment goals for smarter fund selection.


Don’t chase trends. Evaluate mutual funds on fundamentals, not just flair. Look at long-term returns, risk metrics, and fund manager style before investing.


Summary Table: Recency Bias – Past Returns Trap

Investor Types Table
Investor Type Avg. Return (3-5 Yr CAGR) Avg. Risk (Volatility) Avg. Investor Behaviour
Recency Bias Investor 5% – 7% High Enters late, chases past winners, exits in panic
Disciplined Investor 9% – 11% Medium Checks 3–5 year data, selects diversified funds
Passive Trend Follower 6% – 8% High Follows news tips, lacks due diligence

Dr. Satish Vadapalli
Research Analyst