Momentum vs Value Strategies in Mutual Funds

Introduction

Mutual fund investors often hear the terms “Momentum” and “Value” — but what do they really mean, and how do they impact your returns? These are two widely used factor-based investment strategies, and each has its own strengths, timing, and temperament.

In this blog, we break down the difference between Momentum and Value investing in mutual funds and show you how each performs through the journey of two investors — Rahul and Sneha.

05/06/2025

What Is Momentum Strategy?

Momentum investing is about chasing recent winners. Funds using this strategy invest in stocks that have performed well recently, assuming the trend will continue in the short to medium term.

Think of it like surfing the wave — catch the trend, ride the rally, exit before it breaks.

Works best in bull markets and rising sectors.
May fall sharply when momentum breaks or reverses.

What Is Value Strategy?

Value investing is the opposite — it’s about finding undervalued gems. These funds invest in fundamentally strong stocks that are currently trading below their intrinsic value. Think of it as patient investing — buy low, wait for the value to unlock over time. Works best in recoveries and sideways markets.
May underperform during high-growth bull markets.

Real-Life Example: Rahul (Momentum) vs. Sneha (Value)

  • Rahul started SIPs in a Momentum Mutual Fund in Jan 2020. He saw quick gains in 2021 (tech, midcaps soared), earning +28% CAGR that year.
    But in 2022, as markets reversed, his fund fell -12%, and he panicked, stopping SIPs.
  • Sneha, invested in a Value Fund, saw slow growth — only +7% in 2021. But during the correction in 2022, her portfolio remained stable and rebounded well in 2023–24, averaging 11.4% CAGR over 4 years, while Rahul ended with 9.8% CAGR.

    Key Differences

Momentum vs Value Funds
Feature Momentum Funds Value Funds
Stock Focus Recent winners Undervalued, strong fundamentals
Performance Pattern High in bull runs, sharp falls Steady, long-term growth
Ideal Investor Type Aggressive, trend-seekers Patient, long-term thinkers
Volatility High Medium

Conclusion

Momentum is for those who love speed, while value is for those who value patience. Both strategies work — but only if the investor matches the fund’s temperament. Choose wisely!


Review your risk appetite and time horizon. If you can handle volatility, momentum might suit you. If you prefer stability, value investing could be your path.


Summary Table: Momentum vs Value Strategies

Strategy Comparison Table
Strategy Avg. Return (5 Yr CAGR) Avg. Risk (Volatility) Avg. Investor Behaviour
Momentum Funds 12% – 15% High Impulsive, prone to panic exits
Value Funds 10% – 12% Medium Patient, disciplined SIPs
No Strategy 6% – 9% High Random, emotionally driven

Dr. Satish Vadapalli
Research Analyst